I Own This Best-Selling Rug from Pottery Barn — Here’s Why It’s So Great

Amrita ThakkarEditor of Style & Design
Amrita ThakkarEditor of Style & Design
I cover style and design, and I have three years of experience in the home space. My work has appeared on Taste of Home, Family Handyman, Reader's Digest, Yahoo, and MSN. When I'm not writing, you'll find me bouncing to my latest hobby: climbing, yoga, crocheting, or something brand new.
published Dec 20, 2023
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Capitola Hand-Tufted Wool Rug
Credit: Pottery Barn

Truthfully, I’ve never been a rug person. I grew up in a desert environment where rugs and carpeting meant dust allergies galore, so by the time I moved to a drier, cooler climate, I’d long given up on the idea of sinking my feet into rugs’ soft goodness. I wasn’t even sure I knew the process around how to buy a rug!

Credit: Amrita Thakkar

However, when I had the opportunity to try out one of Pottery Barn’s best-selling rugs, I was intrigued. I opted for the Capitola Hand Tufted Wool Rug in Indigo in the size 5-foot-by-8-foot size, and when I received it I was immediately impressed. I was hoping for a rug that my feet would just sink into, and this 100% wool rug delivered on that front. I love the feel of shag rugs but not the look, so this is a happy middle ground if you’re looking for something that is super-soft but also stylish and easy to vacuum. As a bonus, the rug is part of the “Made by Her” project, which facilitates teaching new skills to craftswomen in Asia, which sounds like a nice initiative.  

The color wasn’t as blue as I was hoping, but that might be down to personal preference — so if you prefer something subtle, this is perfect. The Capitola has plenty of color options, too — the Flagstone/Smoke colorway would work great if you want something more saturated. However, the design fits perfectly into my living room’s mid-century modern aesthetic, and the pattern adds visual interest in a space otherwise filled with solid shades. The one thing that immediately jumped out to me is how it pulled the room together — my couch now has a visual anchor sitting beneath it, which creates a sense of grounding. 

Credit: Amrita Thakkar

Aesthetics aside, the 0.5” thickness is perfect for absorbing a little bit of extra sound — and because I live in an apartment, I’m sure my downstairs neighbors are thankful! All in all, it’s the perfect cozy touch for the Midwest winter, and I can definitely see it keeping its place in my living room for many years to come. 

Buy: Capitola Hand-Tufted Wool Rug, 5′ x 8′, $399

More to Love from Apartment Therapy